Energizer making a dash out of the pack towards the graphite production finish line
The fact that Energizer Resources Inc. (TSX: EGZ | OTCQB: ENZR) had a pilot plant operating when most of the rest of the graphite pack were just discovering the mineral shows the level of seriousness of the company. It has leapt ahead in the Feasibility Study race and is now in the final straight for a production decision with a putative start date in late 2017.
Energizer Resources’ prime focus is the exploration and development of its 100%-owned Molo/Green Giant Project located in the extreme south of the island nation of Madagascar off the east coast of Africa. This project is vast and thus encompasses different mineralisations. However at that time I first met them over five years ago it was primarily a Vanadium story, with a sideline in the then barely known graphite.
Time has moved on the graphite moved to the fore as Vanadium fell afoul of the steel industry retraction and graphite moved up due to the battery storage surge. Paradoxically though both of these very different minerals have applications in energy storage. Energizer refocused onto graphite and has now reached the advanced design phase. Recent financings have essentially got the company covered through to the mine build decision. In another recent development an investment bank has been secured to line up an offtaker/partner for the potential output.
Therefore it looks like another “hare & tortoise” situation where a company that had largely fallen off the public radar screen has silently crept up and got ahead of those that were more intent on blowing their own trumpets but not actually doing anything. As a bonus, if added value was needed, it comes with a Vanadium “option” embedded within it for future consideration or spin-out.
A Refresher on Molo/Green Giant
This concession is located 145 km SE of the port city of Tulear with a land position consisting of 36 licenses covering around 225 km².
Get our daily investorintel update
The property is located in an area that has good access via a network of seasonal secondary roads from the village of Fotadrevo, which in turn has access to a regional road system that leads to the regional capital of Toliara. Unlike the typical image of Madagascar as lush jungle the part of the island where the property is located in the rain-shadow and thus it has a dry semi‐desert climate subjected to seasonal cyclonic rainfall.
The goal at the current time is to get a Front End Engineering Design Study (FEED Study) completed for the Molo graphite project. The FEED Study is being undertaken in order to determine potential development path options that have been presented to Energizer by prospective strategic partners. The current timetable has a 4Q17 start to construction and production in late 2018.
Graphite Potential Crystallises
The PEA study, working on the assumption of open-pit mining, was completed in February 2013. The company initially had a target for a production start-up in 2015, with an output capacity of between 50,000 and 150,000 tpa, but that fell afoul of the market’s grim financing conditions. Energizer’s technical partner DRA was designing the mine with three 50,000-tonne modules, whereby the Molo mine would begin initially at 50,000 tpa, but could expand to produce additional graphite as the market requires.
Then in February 2015 Energizer announced the results of its Feasibility Study. The main metrics were:
- Post-tax: NPV ( at 10% ) of US$390mn
- Post-tax: IRR of 31.2%
- Payback in 4.84 years
- Capex of US$149.9 million (down from $162mn in the PEA)
- OpEx per tonne of concentrate (Year 3 onward) of US$353
- Transportation per tonne of concentrate (from mine to port Year 3 onward) of US$182
- Transportation per tonne of concentrate (from Madagascar Port to European Customer Port from Year 3 onward) of US$155
- Average annual production of concentrate of 53,017 tonnes
- Life of Mine – 26 years
- Graphite concentrate sale price (US$/tonne at Start Up – 2017) US$1,689 per tonne
- Average Head Grade of 7.04%
- Average ore mined per annum 856,701 tonnes
- Average stripping ratio of a very low 0.81:1
With the ball rolling on the FEED study and significant financing in the door the company is now set upon the task of finding the largely financing tranche.
Hiring a Matchmaker
In mid-July the company announced that it had appointed London-based HCF International Advisers as its advisor in negotiating and structuring strategic partnerships, off take agreements and debt financing. HCF is an independent corporate finance advisory boutique based in London, UK and focused on the global natural resources and infrastructure sectors.
Since it was established in 2003, HCF has executed transactions with a combined value exceeding USD$12bn. Notably, HCF advised Turquoise Hills Resources on the introduction of Rio Tinto as a 19.9% strategic equity investor, and with the structuring and raising of the US$4bn project financing to develop the Oyu Tolgoi Copper-Gold Project in Mongolia.
Funds Start to Flow
It was a good sign to the marketplace when Energizer announced in recent days that investment funds managed by Goodman & Company, an affiliate of Dundee, purchased CAD$6mn in shares in the recent non-brokered private placement. This took Goodman’s stake in Energizer to just under 20%.
The total issue was an offering of 96,064,286 common shares at a price of CAD$0.07 per share for aggregate gross proceeds of CAD$6,724,500. Sprott Asset Management and significant existing shareholders represented the remaining investors.
The stock price of Energizer lifted slightly but clearly the market has taken its eye off this story as the market cap is almost derisory compared to many far less advanced (and more challenged) players in the graphite space. This must make it a potential acquisition target, but we suspect the stock price will start to move up from here on out.
The net proceeds of the offering will be used to fund the completion of the FEED Study.
The Resource & Reserve
The mineral resource for the Molo deposit the last time we looked at it consisted of:
- a Measured resource of 23.62mn tonnes grading 6.32% C
- an Indicated resource of 76.75mn tonnes grading 6.25% C
- an Inferred resource of 40.91mn tonnes at 5.78% C
This gives a combined total of 141.28mn tonnes at 6.13%C. A cut-off grade of 4% C was used for the “high grade” zones and 2% C for the “low grade” zones. Interestingly while the ‘high’ grade resource occurs within the ‘low’ grade resource, each was estimated and reported separately. The resource remains open along strike and to depth.
The reserves consists of:
- Proven – 14,170,000 tonnes at 7%
- Probable – 8,367,000 tonnes at 7.04%
- Proven and Probable – 22,437,000 tonnes at 7.02%
Energizer has ventured that Molo will be the one of the world’s largest known single source deposits of high-grade graphite. The company claims that Molo’s size and scalability will be a barrier to entry for other producers.
In light of this project’s position in East Africa I can’t help thinking that an Australian listing would glean the company more love. After all it’s a long way from Toronto for investors to focus their spyglass but just across the pond for Australian investors who have traditionally “done” East Africa with more ease.
In any case, Energizer has survived the lean years after the end of the brief Graphite Boom and shown itself to be immensely adaptable having done a timely de-emphasizing of Vanadium just when that metal faded. The potential for V in the battery space is only starting to be recognized so Energizer has a foot in two technologies, so to speak.
Graphite has been the laggard in the three elements crucial to Lithium Ion batteries, with Lithium and Cobalt making a dash while graphite has been trailing, possibly because it was not clear which of the players would be the survivors.
Graphite is likely to regain its attraction to mining investors at least up until such time as there are enough Western producers to allay supply fears. That Dundee waded in with such a significant investment shows that selectively the smart money is trying to pick the winners and avoid the never-gonnabes. Energizer, with its Feasibility Study under its belt, and FEED study coming down the pike, has barged its way to near the front of the pack. This is essentially a reiteration of the same idea I have propagated in lithium and REEs that the first few sizeable projects through the gate effectively kill off the prospects of latecomers (no matter what their virtues might be).
With Dundee making a vote of confidence and the hunt for an offtaker/strategic partner hotting up, it would appear that Energizer is making a dash out of the pack towards the production finish line.
Christopher Ecclestone is the EU Editor for InvestorIntel and is a Principal and mining strategist at Hallgarten & Company in London. Prior to founding Hallgarten ... <Read more about Christopher Ecclestone>